I have long been a bit ambivalent about Italian Renaissance art, in that, with a lot of it, I greatly admire it without actually
liking it all that much. I have no doubt StLukes will lynch me for quoting Georgia O'Keeffe here, who was more blunt: she found much of it "vulgar" when she finally got to see it in person in Italy. Now, she wasn't half as great an artist as Michelangelo, but I know exactly what she meant.
Anyway, I now and then run into exceptions. Today someone posted this on Twitter:
View attachment 29929
Altobello Melone (c1490-c1543) - The Road to Emmaus, c 1516. Oil on panel.
Never heard of the artist before. Is it a particularly great painting? I have no idea, and I don't particularly care (I leave such weighty matters to learned professors of art), but it somehow manages to speak to me in a way that the Sistine Chapel fails to do. Heresy, I'm sure. I once saw an article about amusing things kids wrote in school exams; one girl claimed that Joan of Arc was "burned to a steak". And I'm sure I'll now suffer the same fate.
As always, I must of course add the caveat that I have never seen any of the famous stuff in person, so I can only judge reproductions. Perhaps, when I'm rich enough to go visit Florence, I'll walk into the Sistine and promptly suffer a case of Stendhal syndrome.
This problem of reproduction is not an insignificant one. I never thought much of Rembrandt. Neither did my uncle, who was a pretty solid artist himself. We both had the same complaint: brownish, yellowish old things without texture or nuance. But of course, we had only seen small reproductions in old books. Then my uncle visited Europe and when he came back told me he was particularly blown away by the Rembrandts! I finally got a sense of what he was on about when really good reproductions began to become available on the web (one more reason why, while I'm a bit of a Luddite, I don't reject any and all technology, and definitely not the web!) So now I have turned into a Rembrandt fan.
Who knows, perhaps I'll even enjoy Wagner if I could attend a live performance...